Misuse of Rape Laws, Legal Discrimination and Media Trials
Audio recording
Open audioCase Study and Investigative Report
Organisation: Aid For Men Foundation
News analysed: The report titled “OC Took Signatures on a Compromise Deed After Rape!” published by RTV, and the related incident.
Key focus: Misuse of rape law, the reality of relationships breaking down after long-term acquaintance, consensual sexual relations and adultery being portrayed as rape, Section 497 and overall legal discrimination, media trials that shape subconscious opinion, and the demand for gender-neutral law.
1. Background and the Actual Structure of the Incident
The published report accuses Iftekhar Hossain, the acting officer-in-charge (OC) of Konabari Police Station under Gazipur Metropolitan Police (GMP), of rape, threats to kill, and forcing the complainant to sign a compromise deed. According to the complainant's account in the report, the two became close about one year and five months ago after getting acquainted. Later, promises of marriage, the breakdown of the relationship, distance between them, financial dealings, and allegations about the compromise deed came to light.
When the incident is examined from the case-study perspective of Aid For Men Foundation, the stages appear to have been—long-term acquaintance, closeness, then consensual sexual relations and adultery, and then the breakdown of the relationship. Ignoring this reality, the matter has been presented directly as ‘rape’ after the relationship ended. When a dispute arising from a breakdown is recast as forced rape after a long acquaintance and closeness, followed by consensual sexual relations and adultery, the tendency raises serious questions about the very purpose of rape law.
2. Consensual Sexual Relations and Adultery Versus the Tendency to Manufacture Rape
The clearest point in the analysis of Aid For Men Foundation is this: when the incident is examined closely, it shows that after a long acquaintance and closeness, the two engaged in consensual sexual relations and adultery, and then the relationship broke down. However, after the breakdown and the distance that developed between them, that consensual sexual relationship is now being turned into rape.
In such cases, rape cases based on promises of marriage are often used as a major weapon. When a relationship breaks down after consensual or extramarital involvement, a man can easily be charged with rape on the pretext of a promise of marriage, and the publicised incident is one such example. Yet when a relationship ends or distance develops between the two, women can easily file such cases, while men in the same situation have no such legal recourse or remedy. As a result, consensual sexual relations are turned into rape, and the accused man is placed at severe legal and social risk before any investigation.
3. Section 497, Overall Impunity for Women, and the Reality of Leaving Men Legally Powerless
In a deeper analysis of such incidents, Aid For Men Foundation highlights the one-sided discrimination in existing law:
- Section 497 of the Penal Code and the legal limits on a husband seeking punishment: Under the existing Section 497, if a man's wife engages in adultery, the husband cannot seek punishment against the wife, and there is no legal provision for punishing the wife through the law. Moreover, this law grants women a form of impunity in cases of adultery or illicit relationships. Yet men have no right or opportunity to obtain justice when a relationship or trust breaks down. It is clear from this that a man cannot legally seek punishment for his wife's illicit relationship, extramarital affair or adultery; the state's law has made no provision to bring the wife under punishment, leaving men in a legally helpless position.
- General impunity for women in any illicit relationship: Not only married wives, but women in general face no provision under existing law for punishment if they engage in any form of illicit relationship, whether adultery, extramarital affair, or sexual relations while unmarried. A similar discrimination is seen in rape cases based on promises of marriage: if an unmarried woman engages in consensual sexual relations with an unmarried man, the man can still become the accused in a rape case after the relationship ends, while no case or punishment is provided against the woman. Yet the woman was equally involved in that illicit relationship.
- The reality of marriage for a man after a breakdown and for an established man: Similarly, if a woman engages in sexual relations before a relationship or in any other way, then ends the relationship and later marries another established man, the man who was harmed after the breakup has no opportunity to file a rape case against that woman.
- Two-sided legal discrimination: On one side, women face no full impunity or punishment provision for any form of illicit relationship or for the breakdown of a relationship and distance between partners; on the other side, men face serious accusations such as promise-of-marriage or rape charges. According to Aid For Men Foundation, this one-sided system is clear legal discrimination.
4. Media Trial, Targeting and the Influence on Subconscious Minds
Media presentation and media trial are another alarming aspect of this incident. Although the report kept the complainant's identity confidential, the name, photograph and rank of the accused police officer were published. The headline of RTV (“OC Took Signatures on a Compromise Deed After Rape!”) and its presentation have been framed in a way that, at first glance, portrays the accused man as a rapist.
According to the observations of Aid For Men Foundation:
- Creating a ‘rapist’ belief in the subconscious mind: Through a sensational headline and a report with a photograph, the ‘belief’ or idea that the man in question committed rape is planted in the subconscious mind of the general public. As a result, before any judicial or investigative process is completed, a tendency arises to prove the man guilty or a rapist through a media trial.
- Targeting, framing and defamation: Because he is a man and a member of a state force, he has been placed within a particular frame and defamed. Many readers or viewers react merely by reading the headline without verifying the full incident, and as a result the man's social standing and self-respect are severely damaged before any investigation.
5. Professional Risk and Questions of Balance
Members of the civil service or law enforcement agencies face a risk of losing their jobs or facing serious administrative punishment on the basis of preliminary allegations, due to strict discipline and conduct rules. According to Aid For Men Foundation, the tendency to turn a relationship, which arose after long-term acquaintance and closeness, consensual sexual relations and adultery, and subsequent breakdown and distance, into rape, and thereby to harm the other party socially and professionally on one side's accusation, runs against justice and balance.
Conclusion
The clear position of Aid For Men Foundation is that this incident is not, in fact, rape, but rather an adulterous or illicit relationship that arose after a long acquaintance and closeness, which is being given the form of rape after the relationship broke down and distance developed. Aid For Men Foundation in no way supports this OC's extramarital relationship. In our view, in such cases both this woman and the police officer or man involved should be considered offenders and brought under punishment. The gender bias and discrimination against men created by granting women impunity increase the scope for misuse of the law for money and personal gain, and also make rape law controversial. Therefore, if punishment is to be given, it must be given to both, and if the law is made gender-neutral, such incidents will not occur in future—this is the firm position of Aid For Men Foundation.
.png&w=128&q=75)